MPS Proposes Trial to Cut Costs of Medical Malpractice Claims

Posted:

The Medical Protection Society has proposed a “pre-action protocol” on a trial basis, which it hopes will be a long-term solution to the costs of medical malpractice claims in Ireland.

Due to the expenses involved in supporting legal action, the costs of medical malpractice claims in Ireland can be sky high. A recently proposed “pre-action protocol” by the Medical Protection Society (MPS) – an organisation that provides legal help to medical professionals – aims to cut the costs of medical malpractice claims and reduce the length of time it takes for claims to be resolved.

The protocol encourages openness and transparency between solicitors acting on behalf of plaintiffs and defendants, so that the opportunity exists for medical malpractice claims to be investigated and resolved before court action is necessary. If successful, it should cut the costs of medical malpractice claims by creating a less adversarial process and by using mediation to settle claims quicker.

The MPS´s Director of Claims – Emma Hallinan – is proposing that the protocol be trialled voluntarily before legislation is introduced to compel solicitors to take advantage of this option. She said “We recognise the important role that the MPS must play, and have committed to trialling procedural reform before it is introduced in statute. We are in the process of writing to plaintiff lawyers with large medical negligence practices to request that they work with us to pilot this.”

Currently in England and Wales financial penalties are imposed on solicitors who go straight to litigation without first attempting some form of mediation. In the MPS´s proposed trial, a tariff of general damages would be used – similar to the Book of Quantum – to calculate the “value” of an injury caused by medical malpractice.

The tariff would provide a scale of general damages for specific physical injuries from dental damage to catastrophic brain injuries. General damages for loss of amenity and emotional injuries – as well as special damages for the financial costs of medical malpractice – would still have to be resolved by negotiation, but many observers looking at the MPS´s proposals are in agreement that it is a step in the right direction for lowering the costs of medical malpractice claims in Ireland.